Divide and Rule

What are the stakes for Kashmir’s border communities in the ongoing struggle for azadi from India? Those who question Kashmir’s right to self-determination invariably fall back on its diverse ethnic and religious minorities to reject Kashmiri aspirations for azadi. The standard iteration of this narrative is that Kashmir cannot be reduced to the Valley, nor can its diverse populations, which include Dards, Purigs, Baltis, Botos, and Brogpas among others, be expected to conform to the Kashmiri Muslim desire for freedom from Indian rule.

A slightly different version of the same narrative hones in on the “self” in self-determination, stressing the self as fragmented and heterogeneous, and therefore also politically divided. Such dominant narratives, however, almost never represent border communities as political subjects in their own right. Instead, their “difference” from Kashmiris, particularly from Kashmiri Muslims, is used to frame the Kashmiri struggle for self-determination as parochial and territorially limited in order to render it morally and politically illegitimate.

We can ask whether this standard narrative is truly invested in acknowledging the everyday struggles of border communities, whose lives have become deeply entwined with the logic and operations of a military state. To what extent is this narrative meant to detract from the foundational question of Kashmir’s disputed political status in order to reinforce the justness and legitimacy of India’s rule over Kashmir? Why is it that instead of genuinely engaging with the political aspirations and differences of border communities, their “otherness” is repeatedly used to shore up public apathy against Kashmir’s right to self-determination? And, when and how did plurality in Kashmir become a justification for India’s continued hold over an occupied territory?

Such dominant narratives, however, almost never represent border communities as political subjects in their own right. Instead, their “difference” from Kashmiris, particularly from Kashmiri Muslims, is used to frame the Kashmiri struggle for self-determination as parochial and territorially limited.

Those who speak on behalf of these communities and tout their “difference” as a justification for the political status quo seem to care little about what it means to live on the border, on the state’s margins, to be asked to offer their lives, land, and resources to maintain India’s security and territoriality. The most visible institutional and symbolic expression of the Indian state along the LoC is the Indian military, not its democracy, nor its sprawling shopping malls and arcades, nor its educational and healthcare institutions. In these spaces humans, horses, and cattle, cannot move freely: at the slightest pretext of a cross-border threat, people are expected to clear their fields for guns, ammunition, and landmines.

These are spaces where villagers are repeatedly displaced by wars or cross-border shelling and where civilian deaths and injuries count as collateral damage. These are also spaces where nostalgia for the past runs deep and imaginaries of a borderless world offer the hope of an alternative future for young men and women, one in which they are not just military recruits or porters, quite literally ferrying the burden of the state on their shoulders. In these spaces, conventional narratives of nation and nationalism are fiercely challenged on a daily basis, through music, poetry, and the persistent desire to connect with distant friends and relatives from across the border.

 

The invocation of “difference” is, however, hardly ever accompanied with the sincere desire to engage with the complex political identities of border communities, the contexts in which they were produced and the ways in which these are expressed and often stifled. Clearly, ethnic/religious/linguistic communities in Kashmir are far from homogeneous. For instance, Ladakh has a mix of Buddhist and Shi’a Muslims while Kashmir is predominantly Sunni Muslim. People in Kashmir speak Koshur while those in Ladakh either speak Purig, Balti, Ladakhi, or Shina, or a combination of all four.

Once people are reduced to their representational identities, they become easily manoeuvrable, providing statistics for the state to tally everything from population to health indices to the levels and extent of patriotism and national loyalty.

But while such plurality is supposedly a sign of India’s democratic vitality, in Kashmir it becomes a curse, used often to pit one difference against another; to pitch certain political aspirations as genuine and to label others as invalid, even seditious; and to read people’s sentiments and actions as either pro-Indian or pro-Pakistani.

The politics of identity in Kashmir, much like elsewhere, is deeply imbricated with the everyday operations of statecraft. Such operations take on more urgency in occupied zones as governments create new or intensify existing divisions to build their legitimacy, one identity at a time. The foregrounding of difference suggests a state that has perfected the art of governance through fragmentations, using old colonial methods for new political designs, whereby linguistic, regional, and religious/sectarian differences translate into “divisions” or “fault lines,” making the Kashmir dispute an “intractable” one. Therefore in Kashmir today, it should come as no surprise that we have division between the Mallas and the Hanji, discord between Kashmiri and Gujjar, a divide between the gam (village) and the shahar (city), in addition to the longstanding battle between Pandits and Muslims, which has of course sparked much national interest, given its easy alignments with the explicitly Hindu and Brahminical orientation of Indian politics.

The thousand selves that have emerged within the context of years of representational and identity politics in Kashmir did not evolve organically on their own but were crafted or intensified by the state and its agents to achieve multiple political ends. From creating voting blocs to transforming linguistic/religious/regional divisions into insurmountable political barriers, the state has used development, patronage, and elections to divide populations and shift attention from Kashmir’s long-term political settlement to the mechanics of state formation. Once people are reduced to their representational identities, they become easily manoeuvrable, providing statistics for the state to tally everything from population to health indices to the levels and extent of patriotism and national loyalty.

 

In the border province of Gurez last year, the PDP and NC both attracted voters through a mix of theatrics and “election goodies,” which included supplying them with snow boots, cellphones, and money. In Kargil, several years ago, gifting a fat hen and distributing it among those who could mobilise voters served a similar purpose. Such was the intensity of the PDP-NC animosity in Gurez in 2015 that political adversaries refused to attend the same mosque or pray together.

In this case, we see the “self” fractured along party lines, and yoked more broadly to the banal workings of “Indian democracy.” Compared to these party affiliations, which seem fleeting and eventually reconcilable, other identities to us (the regional, religious variety) appear more ahistoric and primordial. I do not wish to discount people’s political agency, their religious or regional affinities and aspirations, or their cultural and linguistic differences. And yet there is an urgent need to foreground how the politics of the “self” has been mobilised by the state to defer Kashmir’s political settlement either by actively encouraging political/regional divisions or by pitting one identity or political aspiration against another.

For instance, the demand of a Union Territory in Leh is strategically deployed at critical moments to inflame regional and religious divisions between Ladakh and Kashmir. Kargilis, who are mostly Shi’a Muslim, reject the UT demand in favor of Greater Ladakh so they can revitalize their broken ties with Baltistan. Other, smaller minorities in Ladakh, such as Brogpas, foreground their unique “racial” status as Aryans to differentiate themselves from other Ladakhis. In recent years, the RSS has politicised this difference to portray these minorities as authentically Hindu, so it can claim and Hinduise Kashmir’s borders.

If we shift attention to the larger political and historic issue of Kashmir’s unresolved status that has shaped the lives of Ladakhis, Kargilis, Gujjars, Brogpas, and Kashmiris alike, we see them not as fragments but as allies in their common struggle against the deferment of the Kashmir crisis

I see these political identities as the outcome of the same state apparatus that has continually stalled Kashmir’s political settlement in the name of India’s national interest. In the flurry of debates on Kashmir in which Ladakh, Kashmir, and Jammu are seen as politically divided entities, there is a conveniently brushed aside foundational truth. Jammu and Kashmir is a disputed territory and has been since 1947. The relentless focus on J&K’s fragmented politics by progressives and conservatives alike is oriented to deferring its political resolution, to hold on to Kashmir a wee bit longer.

J&K’s unresolved status is the reason why everyone in the state has suffered, whether it is because of a brutal military occupation, because of the LoC that violently splits people and communities, or because of collaborative governments that purposefully play divide and rule. If we shift attention to the larger political and historic issue of Kashmir’s unresolved status that has shaped the lives of Ladakhis, Kargilis, Gujjars, Brogpas, and Kashmiris alike, we see them not as fragments but as allies in their common struggle against the deferment of the Kashmir crisis—a crisis that can only be resolved in accordance with people’s aspirations.

Such an alignment would make visible the mechanics of how to best devise inclusive models of a plebiscite. But without the political commitment and honesty required to accept Kashmir’s temporary accession to India, all we hear are the laments of the progressives, left-liberals, as well as the ultra-conservatives alike, over fractured Kashmiri identities. Those who supposedly represent the interests of Kashmir’s marginalised groups should indeed be at the forefront of demanding Kashmir’s political resolution, unless, of course, their intention is to prop up the bogey of difference to stifle challenges to the hegemonic idea of Indian nationhood, in which Kashmir will always remain a prized territory and an integral part of India. The political status quo and violent borders do little to create genuine spaces for dialogue and dissent for those whose difference is deployed to undermine Kashmir’s disputed political status.

9 Comments

  • Reply December 21, 2025

    Lex Casino für Spieler

    Der Mindesteinzahlungsbetrag beträgt 10 €. Ob Anfänger oder High Roller – PlayOJO bietet jedem ein maßgeschneidertes Erlebnis, das begeistert und
    sich von der Masse abhebt. Spieler loben die Ehrlichkeit und die vielfältigen Angebote, die nicht nur unterhalten, sondern auch Vertrauen schaffen.
    In der heutigen Zeit spielen immer mehr Casino Fans aus Deutschland mobil mit einem Smartphone oder Tablet.

    Der Einsatz bei den Play OJO Freispielen liegt bei 0,10 Euro
    und der Gewinn aus den Freespins unterliegt keinen Umsatzanforderungen. Ja, 50 Freispiele ohne Umsatzbedingungen als Willkommensbonus.
    Die Plattform punktet mit schnellen Auszahlungen, benutzerfreundlichem Design und
    einem hervorragenden mobilen Erlebnis – ideal für moderne Glücksspieler.
    PlayOJO hat sich als eines der transparentesten und spielerfreundlichsten Online-Casinos etabliert.

    In regelmäßigen Abständen erhalten Sie einen Hinweis über Ihre
    bisherige Spielzeit. Außerdem würden Sie mehr Freispiele und maßgeschneiderte Boni erwarten. Halten Sie treu zu Ihren PlayOJO Spielotheken Erfahrungen, könnten Sie per Mail eine Einladung
    erhalten, VIP zu werden. Als angemeldeter Spieler steigen Sie mit Einsätzen im Level auf und schalten so
    Drehungen am Glücksrad frei, das Ihnen Freispiele einbringt.
    Sie können sogar gezielt PlayOJO Online Spiele einsehen, an denen Sie bei Einsätzen mehr Cashback zurückerhalten (siehe Promos weiter oben).

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/vegas-casino-freispiele-ihr-weg-zu-gewinnen-ohne-risiko/

  • Reply December 21, 2025

    evolve casino ratgeber

    Das Spa bietet den Standard-Service wie Massagen, Gesichtsbehandlungen, Haar- und Nagelbehandlungen sowie Salon-Services.
    Das Hotel verfügt zudem über mehrere Bars im gesamten Gebäude sowie ein Restaurant
    im Eiffelturm. Martorano hat eine italienische Speisekarte und Burger Brasserie Sports Grill bietet eine Sport-Bar Atmosphäre und spärlich bekleidet Kellnerinnen.
    Als Besonderheit genießen die Gäste in den Badezimmern Kosmetikartikel.
    Eine Dusche und eine Badewanne gehören zum Interieur
    der Badezimmer. Erfrischende Getränke an der Poolbar und wohlige Entspannung im Whirlpool (gegen Gebühr) bringen alle Wasserratten in die beste Stimmung.
    Sind die Hotelzimmer mit einer Klimaanlage ausgestattet?
    Versuchen Sie Ihr Glück im Casino, lassen Sie sich in den vielfältigen Restaurants mit Gaumenfreuden verwöhnen und finden Sie entspannende Momente
    im Spa.
    Sie sehen etwas altmodisch aus, obwohl die Suiten Whirlpool-Badewannen bieten .

    Die Badezimmer sind mit Marmorwaschtischen, separaten Duschen und Badewannen, Schönheitsspiegeln und Haartrocknern ausgestattet.
    Kostenlose Ortsgespräche und WLAN sind in der obligatorischen Resortgebühr der Unterkunft enthalten. Zu den Standardeinrichtungen in allen Zimmern gehören ein Flachbild-TV mit Kabelkanälen, ein Mini-Kühlschrank , ein Bügeleisen / -brett , ein Kofferständer und ein Safe .
    Die Böden sind mit grauen Vierpassmustern ausgelegt und die Badezimmer sind mit Marmor ausgekleidet.
    Zu den weiteren Annehmlichkeiten gehören ein Spa , ein Fitnessraum , kostenfreies WLAN und Parkplätze (gegen Gebühr).

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/evolve-casino-bonus-codes-ihr-umfassender-leitfaden/

  • Reply December 26, 2025

    Red Stag Casino Australia

    Zoome Casino is a premium online gaming platform designed for Australian players seeking an exciting and secure gambling experience.
    Founded by Dama N.V., a company with a strong reputation for delivering high-quality gaming experiences,
    Zoome Casino’s mission is centered around providing a seamless and engaging experience for its players.
    Deposit bonuses, free spins and participation in promotions
    and tournaments give players a real chance to win big, spending significantly less of their own funds.
    Some bonuses may provide additional chances to win, so a player should carefully weigh the
    pros and cons before deciding to refuse a bonus at Zoome online casino Casino .

    With partnerships spanning over 60 leading software developers, the gaming
    catalogue represents the finest selection available in today’s market.
    Understanding these elements helps you make informed decisions
    about where to invest your hard-earned dollars and
    ensures you get maximum value from your gaming sessions.
    Paysafe payments are handled by Dama N.V. Players must verify the legality of online gambling in their local jurisdiction. Pokies
    at Zoome casino generally offer strong return rates, often above 96%.

    The Zoome Casino platform focuses on instant-play gaming,
    meaning everything runs in your browser – no
    software downloads or installation required. Zoome Casino launched in 2022 and quickly became a trusted name for players in Australia.
    Zoome Casino up your gaming experience and join the fun at Zoome Casino today!
    With swift payouts and a dedicated support team at your beck and call, you can focus on what truly matters – the thrill of the game.
    May raise some concerns about jurisdiction, but rest assured that it doesn’t compromise on player safety and fairness.
    Next, log in to your new account and head to the cashier section to make your
    first deposit – you can choose from a range of payment options, including Visa, Mastercard, and various cryptocurrencies like BTC or ETH.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/thrill-awaits-at-lucky-ones-casino/

  • Mobile access supports both iOS and Android operating systems
    with equivalent performance standards. Transaction limits often extend higher for cryptocurrency methods compared
    to traditional payment options. The blockchain-based transaction structure offers additional security through decentralized verification. WinSpirit Casino embraces cryptocurrency payment options including Bitcoin (BTC),
    Litecoin (LTC), Ethereum (ETH), USDT, and Bitcoin Cash.
    The banking system accommodates traditional financial instruments alongside contemporary electronic payment solutions.

    Sun International slot games offer denominations ranging from 1c to R100.
    Our table games use casino value chips that can be purchased from
    the Cash Desk or at the tables. Sun International casinos offer an exciting and entertaining range of casino table games including Roulette, Poker, Blackjack and many more.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/bellagio-resort-overview/

  • Crown Resort’s six star hotel makes up the lower levels of the tower from
    levels 6 to 32, including the protruding lower south east wing of the building.
    The casino floor along with bars, restaurants and other hospitality venues occupy the podium of the
    tower. In June 2016, the casino received final approval from the Planning Assessment Commission on condition that the
    casino met needs proposed by the commission, including adequate public spaces and access.
    These concepts mostly centred around a 213 metres (699 feet) tall hotel tower built on a pier extended 150 metres
    (490 feet) into the harbour. It was developed by Crown Resorts, primarily comprising a hotel and residential apartments,
    while a casino and other hospitality venues make up the rest
    of its floorspace.
    Relax as our dedicated staff ensure a seamless dining experience in the comfort of your room.
    Thoughtful touches from lavish amenities, intuitive technology and dedicated butler service make the Crown Towers Villas experience beyond exceptional.

    The Star Sydney’s casino is open 24/7, complemented by late-night bars and entertainment.

    Nestled in the heart of Barangaroo, Crown Casino Sydney delivers a refined gaming experience
    like no other. Experience premium gaming,
    fine dining, and luxurious hospitality in the heart of
    Sydney Harbour. Our in-house retailer offers a range of luxury Crown products available
    for purchase, including a select range of Crown linen and At Home products.
    Visit the Crown Rewards Desk located on Level 2 to become a member today or you can start the process before your arrival through the Crown Resorts App.
    Our dedicated Sydney team will ensure every detail is tailored to your
    specific needs to deliver an inspiring and impressive experience.
    Treat yourself to a day of pampering at Crown Spa, with a range of exclusive La
    Prairie and Subtle Energies health and beauty treatments designed to help you feel your
    best.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/play-21910-free-casino-games-no-sign-up/

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    play slots online

    As with other bonuses, this bonus comes with terms and
    conditions that you’ll have to meet to withdraw your winnings.
    Every time you deposit some funds, you can claim a reload bonus.
    All these bonuses have terms and conditions called wagering requirements.

    The experts view on the percentage fees and then give attention to those Australian gambling sites which pay more than 86%.
    Examining recommendations is the greatest approach to search for suggestions on Australian gambling sites.
    And after examine Terms & Conditions, make an advance payment, pick up good bonuses
    and so forth. This is probably fine to play slots online
    and make sure that you get large amount of cash.

    Many casinos allow free play so you can explore games, test strategies, and get comfortable before wagering real money.
    We provide in-depth, honest reviews of reputable
    online casinos catering to Australian players. Welcome to our expert casino reviews, where
    we help Australian players find the safest, most rewarding online casinos.
    Most online casinos require verification for security, but some casino bonus offers may feature faster withdrawal processes.
    Enjoy the flexibility of gaming on the go with a mobile casino bonus—a
    popular type of online casino bonus designed specifically for
    players using smartphones or tablets.

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    africa.careers

    online casino accepts paypal us

    References:
    africa.careers

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    csepyl.com

    casino with paypal

    References:
    csepyl.com

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    www.flughafen-jobs.com

    us poker sites that accept paypal

    References:
    http://www.flughafen-jobs.com

Leave a Reply