NO COUNTRY FOR THE POOR (An extract)

For millions of South Africans, Nelson Mandela’s passing signalled the end of an era. Returning home to cover the story, journalist Azad Essa finds his countrymen looking a little lost, insecure of the future, even as they celebrate the life of a great man. Essa travelled around his native South Africa to track the mood of the nation. He notes the deification of this global icon despite the muck and grime of the great swathes of poverty that remain in South Africa two decades after the fall of Apartheid. The celebrations reminded him of contradictions he had seen elsewhere: India.


At seventeen, Mpho Matshimawe, living in the Waterkloof informal settlement just outside Johannesburg, is younger than South Africa’s democracy. She is one of the ‘born frees’, as they are known in local parlance. With no rhythm or rhyme, no lived experience of apartheid. She stood outside her mother’s shack, and projected her voice over the vast puddle that flooded the front yard and separated the two of us. I was visiting the informal camp to ask residents how they felt about Mandela. She will miss him, she told me.

‘I will be eighteen years [in May 2014] but I will not be voting. I will vote when I see things starting to change, but nothing ever changes here.’

Sixty per cent of Africans still farm and graze animals as their primary livelihood, as they have for hundreds of years. Nelson Mandela himself was a cattle herder as a young lad on the hills of Mqhekezweni, in the Eastern Cape. It’s from these same hills where Mandela was born and raised that many of the miners who work the underground for gold and diamonds hundreds of kilometres away, near Johannesburg, also come from. It is also here where so many tears were shed when thirty-four miners were shot dead by policemen at a platinum mine outside the town of Marikana on 16 August 2012.

Described as the most brutal police operation since the end of apartheid, the Marikana massacre is also a cogent reminder of the continued inequality strangling the country. The incident also pushed the ruling ANC to turn against its own supporters, grinding at their loyalties. The workers, in this instance, had had enough. In the past a strike against employers would go on until the ANC would call the unions and instruct an end to the intrusion on business life. This strike however was different. In the days leading up to 16 August, Marikana saw the rise of a new trade union, called the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union (AMCU), who rejected the collusion of the existing National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) at the time, the largest trade union in the country, with employers,.

The demands for a wage hike drew ridicule from the middle classes in the cities. Why did rock drillers want a 300 per cent wage rise, they asked. Few wanted to understand the bigger story here. The collapsing rural economy were forcing thousands to the cities and the mines for work. Each miner was supporting 15–20 people in the farms, where subsistence farming was like flogging a dead cow. The miners were killed when their homes hundreds of kilometres away were already dying.

The project of reconciliation in this country battered by racial hatred and selective privilege and humiliation has always been unfathomable, even unreasonable without the advent of real equality. The incongruity remains a harpoon firmly fixed in the guts of the much cherished rainbow nation democracy, and the hurt is expressed in the serial convulsions of severe criminality, gender abuse, including rape and xenophobia. Both India and South Africa also endure embarrassing accounts of rape, gang rape, corrective rape, gender mutilation and paedophilia. In a society built on patriarchy across all levels, class, race, caste, must we wonder why the disenfranchised are so easily provoked, so easy to ‘snap’, when their everyday is a form of abuse?

Apartheid was a system of separate development, built to retain economic and social dominance, through the fear of ‘the other’. Through the new dispensation, the structure in which this country operated, economically and socially, never altered. The country might have been declared non-racial, but little was done to refocus the ways of seeing each other, especially when there remained tangible differences in the material wealth of different race groups.

The miners of Marikana were described as ‘militant’, ‘dogmatic’, ‘armed’—as the
black folk were once described in this country.  Their demands were ‘unreasonable’ considering the economic climate, ‘regressive’, not unlike the tribals in the backwaters of India.

The conviction with which Mandela sold the dream of coexistence without revenge was the real miracle of South Africa. He managed to almost single-handedly slice though the white minority’s fear of ‘the other’—that is, the black majority—built up through decades of racist dogma of white supremacy. Mandela convinced most whites to buy into the new South Africa; he got most of them to stay.

He allowed white South Africans, and even the other minority, the Indian population, to feel they too could belong. His relationship with Ahmed Kathrada and other struggle veterans from the community, especially the valiant Fatima Meer, tied this community to the fortunes of the ANC.

But the fact that he had to tiptoe close to sainthood, through grandiose calls for forgiveness, offer peace without necessarily offering justice through platforms like the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), and then succumb to foreign economic logic, to be deemed a near saint, is nevertheless deeply troubling.

It is an also an expression of deep-seated racism where his ordinary flaws were subsumed by the personal wants of a minority and the expectation that Mandela’s example guaranteed that the oppressed and black population would remain civil despite their subjugation. As if Mandela had hypnotized a rabid population baying for the blood of the white man that only his death could unravel.

Despite his achievements, the construction of Mandela as a larger-than-life figure, and deity, like Gandhi, is an impossible feat to replicate: a meta-source of future failure for all who follow. Be it leader, or citizen, the pressure on ordinary men and women to follow in the footsteps of a figure whose feats only continue to grow is untenable.

To the outside world, Mandela’s style and rigour came as a huge relief, and his celebrity status did not arrive without problems. He became a darling to the Western world, appealing to liberals and their recent concerns with human rights, justice and political equality without radically upsetting the status quo. The image of Mandela, built up as the anti-Christ, commie-apostate to the white population during his years in prison, was upended overnight. He was the kind of black man they could do business with.

In this way, Mandela the statesman is sometimes compared to Nehru
the statesman after Independence. But a distinction must be made. Whereas Mandela stepped down willingly from politics, Nehru allowed his family to take the reigns of Congress. Moreover, despite Nehru’s ardent opposition to nationalism, which Mandela oft-repeated, the Indian prime minister banned the written or oratory questioning of India’s territorial integrity, holding on to Kashmir forcibly, quashing rebellions in the northeastern states with a bloodied fist.

Mandela’s legacy, flawed as it might be, was in contrast, fiercely democratic.

Twenty years on, however, the expectation of celebratory forgiveness without material improvement to the lives of millions of South Africans, without unhinging the social and economic structure that allowed the separated worlds, or apartheid, to continue in its different forms, is fast becoming untenable itself.

This is not to suggest that South Africans, of all races, have not benefited from an almost bloodless transition under Mandela, or to dispute the fact that some part of the foundation of the country has been laid for it to become the home for all who live in it. It is easy to renounce colour if it protects your privilege. But when colour still, to a large extent, determines access to a better life, it’s only so long before the farce reveals itself.

 

In our new column, ‘Drum Beat’ author and Al Jazeera journalist, Azad Essa distills the soundscape of an emerging new Africa.

10 Comments

  • Reply December 20, 2025

    Spirit Casino Echtgeld

    Die Boni an den Spielautomaten in PSK sind großzügig, ich habe 50
    Freispiele in dieser casino bekommen! Die Gewinnauszahlungen in PSK sind schnell und problemlos, was bei einer
    casino wichtig ist. Das Blackjack in PSK hat die besten Auszahlungsquoten, die
    ich je in casinos gesehen habe. Sie müssen einen kroatischen Ausweis und ein in Kroatien eröffnetes Bankkonto haben, um hier zu spielen
    Mit sicherem Spiel, schnellen Gewinnausschüttungen und zahlreichen Boni
    bietet PSK Casino alles, was Sie für eine aufregende Reise durch die Welt der Glücksspiele benötigen. Entdecken Sie eine reiche Auswahl an beliebten Slots, Tischspielen und Live-Dealer-Spielen. Diese
    App ist direkt im offiziellen Google Play Store verfügbar.
    PSK Casino fördert verantwortungsbewusstes Spielen und bietet Unterstützung für Spieler, die Hilfe
    benötigen. Die App bietet Filteroptionen nach Kategorien, Themen oder Anbietern, um ein individuelles Spielerlebnis zu gewährleisten.
    Das PSK Casino legt großen Wert auf den Kundenservice und bietet seinen Spielern eine
    freundliche und kompetente Unterstützung. Mit einer breiten Auswahl an klassischen und innovativen Casino-Spielen bietet das PSK Casino
    eine spaßige und aufregende Atmosphäre für seine
    Spieler. PSK Casino bietet seinen Spielern in Österreich zuverlässigen und zugänglichen Kundensupport über verschiedene
    Kanäle. PSK Casino ermöglicht seinen Benutzern in Österreich verschiedene Optionen für Ein- und Auszahlungen mit hohen Sicherheits- und Komfortstandards.
    PSK Casino bietet seinen Spielern in Österreich verschiedene
    attraktive Boni und Promotionen, die das Spielerlebnis zusätzlich bereichern.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/casino-of-gold-promo-code-ihr-schlussel-zu-exklusiven-vorteilen/

  • Reply December 21, 2025

    Bizzo Casino Bonus 2026

    Zu meinen Löwen Play Erfahrungen gehören Spielehits wie
    Book of Ra oder Eye of Horus, die für Spaß und Gewinne sorgen.
    Mit einer deutschen Lizenz der GGL ausgestattet, nutzt Löwen Play seinen hohen Bekanntheitsgrad in Deutschland und sichert sich eine Top Position auf dem
    Markt. Anfangs wurden Geldspielautomaten und
    Musikboxen hergestellt und vertrieben. Allerdings sind die anderen Bonusangebote
    des Anbieters nicht zu verachten.
    Denn im Löwen Play Online Casino gibt es auch die Slots von Pragmatic
    Play oder Hacksaw, um nur mal zwei de aktuell so beliebten Slotanbieter nennen. Und genau diese geballte Kernkompetenz in Sachen Automatenunterhaltung ist es, die auch
    bei den Onlineangeboten für beste Löwen Play Erfahrungen sorgt.
    Seit 1952 betreibt das Unternehmen offline Geldspielautonaten.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/nomini-casino-bewertung-eine-umfassende-analyse-fur-deutsche-spieler/

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    Betman Casino Australia

    Lets you block yourself from all licensed online gambling operators in Australia.

    If you ever feel that gambling is starting to affect your life, don’t hesitate to reach out.
    Real money gambling can be exciting, but it also comes with
    risks. At Leon Casino, we believe that gambling should always be fun, light-hearted, and 100% optional.

    A legit casino will never pressure you, delay your payments,
    or dodge your questions.
    Leon Casino treats Australian players like VIPs from day one with bonuses that reward
    bold play and consistency. Premium online casino experience for Australian players since 2015.

    If you feel your gambling is getting out of control, Leon Casino offers responsible gaming tools such as deposit limits, time-out periods,
    and self-exclusion. The mobile version offers the same features
    as desktop, including deposits, withdrawals, promotions, and the
    full game library. It’s essential to remember that casino games are gambling, not a way to make money.
    Also, responsible gambling features like deposit limits, self-exclusion,
    and activity reminders are a sign the casino takes player wellbeing seriously.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/crypto-casinos-top-sites-in-2025/

  • Great bonuses with 1x wagering requirements Limitless has a
    pretty generous no deposit offer, called the daily no-rules bonus.
    Upon confirming your email address, the casino will credit your
    account with 5 free spins. This is the only way to get the offer added to your casino account.

    This is done by clicking on your casino avatar followed
    by selecting “bonuses” and then clicking the “activate” button. To claim the spins,
    sign up for an account via the claim button below and complete the registration process.
    Once done, head over to the “my bonuses” section, scroll to the bottom,
    and enter the bonus code “AUPARTY” in the promo code
    field. If you already have an account with one of those casinos, you must use that same
    account for Mega Medusa.
    We test every bonus before listing it, and regularly re-check them to make sure they’re still valid.
    You’ll find the wheel directly in the casino’s menu under “wheel.” While the amount is small, it’s entirely free
    and carries no wagering requirement or cashout limits. Once
    the admin confirms your follow, the free spins will be added within 24 hours.
    To spin, log in to your account and click the “Lucky Wheel” item in the
    menu.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/lapilanders-casino/

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    best online casino

    This offer comes with a reasonable 30x wagering
    requirement. ‼️ Read our full Bovada Casino
    review and claim an exclusive Bovada bonus code to boost your
    bankroll. The winnings from such slots can be withdrawn immediately without wagering requirements.
    Some titles offer progressive jackpots. The game portfolio includes
    777 Deluxe, A Night with Cleo, and Gold Rush Gus.
    Features like RTP transparency, trusted payment systems, and player
    control tools signal a platform built for serious, long-term play.

    Caesars and Fanatics also have excellent welcome offers as well as exclusive bonuses to play
    games online. These casino bonuses are designed for players making substantial deposits, these offers have higher maximum values but often require larger minimum deposits.
    The best online casinos feature live dealer games, which are streamed live to your computer screen in real time.
    That’s the only place online that offers legal online casino games for real money.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/the-best-free-online-pokies-in-australia-2025-guide/

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    crypto casino pokies

    Crown Sydney offers Electronic Table Games (ETGs) like Roulette and Blackjack.
    Sadly, I couldn’t find slot machines at the gaming hall.
    I found a total of 160 tables and 66 electronic tables in the Crystal
    Room, plus 30 private salons on the Mahogany floor. The staff
    are also helpful and readily available to guide players to accessible areas.

    Crown Direct provides insider access to the best
    rates and deals across Crown Hotels. Experience a secluded tropical pool, tennis court, day spa, as
    well as acclaimed restaurants, bars, and luxury boutiques.
    A luxury hotel where plush living areas, deep soaking baths, and floor-to-ceiling
    windows await you.
    Plus, Crown poker rooms are noted for hosting major
    poker events such as the Aussie Millions Poker Championships (Crown Melbourne) and the Western Classic Poker
    Championships (Crown Perth). Daily tournaments are also the norm with entry fees starting at
    around $50.00 and, for select tournaments, going up to $1,500.
    Due to the high volume of new Casino members, there may be a small wait to complete your membership application. Our dedicated Sydney team will ensure every
    detail is tailored to your specific needs to deliver
    an inspiring and impressive experience. Treat yourself to a day of pampering at Crown Spa, with a range of
    exclusive La Prairie and Subtle Energies health and beauty
    treatments designed to help you feel your best. Indulge
    in world-class fine dining, enjoy a casual meal with
    friends, or relax and unwind in a stylish bar.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/spin-samurai-australian-online-casino-a-comprehensive-o%3Cbr%3Everview/

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    rhea-recrutement.com

    online casinos that accept paypal

    References:
    rhea-recrutement.com

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    seven.mixh.jp

    paypal casino canada

    References:
    seven.mixh.jp

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    teachersconsultancy.com

    online casino for us players paypal

    References:
    teachersconsultancy.com

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    lookingforjob.co

    paypal casino usa

    References:
    lookingforjob.co

Leave a Reply