Tribal Dance

Last month, we were all waiting with bated breath for the Supreme Court decision on the Vedanta Mining issue in the Niyamgiri Hills. The plight of the DongriaKondh tribe due to Vedanta’s plans to mine Bauxite in their lands was to be finally addressed. However, in true legal fashion, the judgement has again been deferred to a later, yet unannounced date. Given the re-emergence of the debate in the highest court of the land, and following a desire to not let at least one cause be forgotten, this seems like a perfect time to remind ourselves of the controversy surrounding this issue.

A quick glance at online forums and western and Indian media coverage of the issue will reveal how dramatically similar this issue is to the movie ‘Avatar’ and the plight of the indigenous people – the Na’vi, so much so that it even convinced ‘Avatar’ director, James Cameron to lend his support to the cause of the DongriaKondh tribe. In fact, readers may even recall an earlier article by a separate columnist using the analogy for a different mining incident concerning another indigenous tribe (The Hills Are Still Alive; Sayantan Neogi, May 2010).

The DongriaKondh is an indigenous tribe found in the hills of Orissa who hack out a meagre sustainable living from the natural surroundings of their region. They are essentially foragers and hunter-gatherers who occasionally dabble in light agriculture for sustenance. Tribal culture, as is so often the case, dictates that their pantheon of gods include deities derived from the natural surroundings. One of their most important deities, in fact, is the very Niyamgiri hill that Vedanta wants to mine.

Vedanta is a FTSE 100 listed company based in the UK, founded by Indian industrialist Anil Agarwal, and headquartered in London, UK. The company has massive mining interests throughout India. The two governments with the most influence over this company, therefore, are the UK and Indian government. And here lies the opportunity to see the marked difference in the environmental and human rights priorities of both governments. The UK government has been extremely vocal in its opposition of Vedanta’s activities regarding the DongriaKondh. The ethically and morally horrifying implications of eradicating the lifestyle of an indigenous tribe is certainly something the UK government would not want to be associated with (perhaps it is an easier choice, given the distance from the problem).

The Indian government, on the other hand, has shown its usual penchant for flip-flopping. After giving initial provisional permission to mine in the area, it was subsequently revoked. Jairam Ramesh, the then Environment Minister, in one of his more efficient stands, stood up against Vedanta. The Environment Department even came out and admitted that giving mining permission to Vedanta was a mistake in the first place. Although Jairam Ramesh was subsequently put in charge of a different ministry, he did manage to put a temporary spanner in Vedanta’s works.

The Supreme Court has revisited this case in the light of the human rights and environmental potential of the situation, and has promised to expedite the process. The DongriaKondh has alternatively stated that it will continue its protest and effort to stop Vedanta even if the SC decides to allow mining.

Being part of the human rights and environmental debate, it is certainly my duty to articulate that allowing Vedanta to continue mining in the Niyamgiri would not only be morally and ethically erroneous but a missed opportunity by the Supreme Court to show that it is the upholder of the rights of weaker sections of India’s diverse societes against the inherent tyranny of industrial progress. To allow an entire way of living to be destroyed for the sake of industrial ambition would be absolutely criminal and disheartening to say the least.

Rohit roy writes the environmental column for Kindle, with desperate intentions to help make a greener world. Currently he is pursuing a PhD in World Trade and Environmental law. His interests include theology, philosophy, good food, Rabindranath and an amateur take on natural sciences.

6 Comments

  • Diese Glücksspiel-Anbieter bieten 200%, 300%, 400% Prozent als Willkommensbonus.
    Bester 200%-500% und mehr Bonus in online Casinos für Österreichische Spieler.

    Was sind die besten Länder für Online-Casinospieler?
    Es ist unser Ziel für Sie relevante Inhalte zu produzieren, indem
    wir online Casinos testen. Finden Sie letzte Info über BetBit Casino – Sportwetten,
    Live Casino und Videoslots mit Bitcoin.
    Go Fish Casino bietet eine Vielzahl von Zahlungsmethoden an, um den Spielern größtmögliche Flexibilität zu gewährleisten. Diese Anbieter bieten eine
    breite Palette an Spieltypen, darunter Baccarat, Bingo, Blackjack, Jackpot Games,
    Keno, Live Casino, Roulette, Scratch Cards, Slots und Video Poker.
    Go Fish Casino Game Providers sind führende Entwickler von Online-Casino-Software, die eine Vielzahl von Spielen für deutsche Spieler anbieten. Für den deutschen Markt bietet das Go Fish Casino
    eine spannende und regulierte Plattform, die
    durch ihre lange Bestehenszeit Vertrauen aufbauen kann.
    Für den deutschen Markt bietet Casino Fiz nicht nur eine benutzerfreundliche Plattform, sondern auch
    eine große Auswahl an Online-Slots, Rubbellosen und einem Live-Casino.
    Casino Fiz, gegründet im September 2008, bietet einen beeindruckenden Willkommensbonus von 400%, der neue Spieler anzieht.

    Casino Dome wird Ihr neues Lieblings Casino online! Unsere Bonusbedingungen sind transparent und unsere
    Kundensupport ist 24/7 verfügbar. Go Fish Casino bietet eine breite Palette an Zahlungsoptionen, einschließlich Kreditkarten (Visa,
    MasterCard), E-Wallets (Skrill/Neteller) und sogar Crypto-Währungen (BTC, ETH, LTC, USDT).
    Eine der Highlights sind die interaktiven i-Slots, die eine
    einzigartige Spielerfahrung bieten.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/drip-casino-promo-code-ihr-leitfaden-zu-exklusiven-vorteilen/

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    instant casino

    However, they remain the preferred choice for high-rollers withdrawing $5,000 or more from an instant
    withdrawal casino, due to thorough bank-level security checks.
    These platforms are regulated by ASIC and offer encrypted, digitally signed transactions.
    Almost every fast payout casino in Australia supports
    crypto for its unmatched speed and security. Crypto is the fastest way
    to cash out at an instant casino in Australia.

    With professional dealers, crystal-clear streams, and interactive features like live chat, they offer an immersive alternative to standard RNG games.
    Online live casinos in Australia bring the casino floor to your
    screen in real time. Wilna van Wyk is an online casino enthusiast with over a decade
    of experience working with some of the world’s biggest gambling affiliates, including Thunderstruck Media and OneTwenty Group.

    As a new player, you can score a generous welcome package
    of up to A$7,500 – and that’s just the beginning!

    You’ll need an account to access the live chat feature, though.
    For example, you could get 50 free spins or a midweek 50%
    bonus, 99 free spins every Friday, and 10% cashback, just to name a few.
    And if you’re concerned about anything, there’s a 24/7 live chat customer support
    option. At the time of writing, it offers 6 different events including Drops & Wins with A$3,000,000 prize
    pool. Assistance is available 24/7 using the on-site
    live chat or the dedicated email address.

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    Sydney casino Australia

    From world-class Japanese cuisine to relaxed al fresco dining, there’s something for every taste and budget.
    Crown Perth is renowned for its vibrant gaming floor, competitive jackpots, and secure environment.
    Crown Perth reserves the right to refuse entry
    to any persons considered unsuitably dressed.The dress standard
    for the Casino is smart casual. The dress standard for
    the Casino is smart casual; customers must be clean,
    neat and tidy at all times.
    Toast with friends at top shelf bars.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/players-club-vip-casino/

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    shop.ororo.co.kr

    online betting with paypal winnersbet

    References:
    shop.ororo.co.kr

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    www.cubexpromax.com

  • Thanks for sharing your knowledge on this topic. It’s much appreciated.

Leave a Reply