Understanding the Underdog

Qafe Banner

So, who is an underdog? The dictionary defines an underdog as a loser/runner-up/second best/small fry and so on. But the term has a far more politically significant connotation in common parlance. To side with the underdog means supporting the wronged, the deprived, the person(s) and/or population group(s) facing socio-economic imbalance, resulting in the denial of entitlements and social justice. This qafeteer tends to agree with this used meaning, rather than the dictionary meaning. However, I continue being baffled by the question of who is an underdog. Is an underdog forever an underdog, and in all situations?

Phrases like “marginalised” and “vulnerable” are used routinely with reference to different population groups, especially in the social development sector that provides me my bread, butter and jam. These are buzzwords with human rights activists and groups: individuals and population groups marginalised socio-economically, culturally and politically are vulnerable to specific kinds and situations of rights violations—with routine denial of social justice. So, such individuals and population segments are underdogs. But who are they? And, are they always already underdogs?

Economic deprivation being one of the most readily recognised markers of marginalisation, let us take the poor of India. That very concept is a problematic one, surely, for “the poor” certainly does not imply one homogeneous, monolithic population group. Even if only economic poverty is taken as the single yardstick, there would hardly be any debate that there are degree differences: not every poor person/family faces abject poverty in the form of continued hunger and starvation. There are differences between rural and urban poverty—with the urban poor having more opportunities for income earning, but less welfare schemes from the government. So, how to decide who is an underdog? Every single person and family facing economic deprivation is an underdog, of course, but is everyone in a similar situation of underdog-hood/-ness? Or, is it that individuals and families facing abject poverty, with two square meals a day being a forgotten phenomenon, more of an underdog than those who can manage two square meals a day once every week or so?

So, how to decide who is an underdog? Every single person and family facing economic deprivation is an underdog, of course, but is everyone in a similar situation of underdog-hood/-ness?

I certainly do not find it easy to answer this apparently simple question and it only becomes even more complicated if we bring in other oppressive criteria. Think of a starving Brahmin family and a half-starving lower caste Dalit family in a village in Haryana. Let’s say that the Brahmin family manages to eat just one meal that leaves everyone hungrier than before once every three days. In contrast, the Dalit family manages at least one square meal—poor in quality and limited in quantity, but a meal nevertheless—everyday and can arrange two square meals at least once every week. Both families are facing hunger and starvation, but there is certainly a difference.

However, the Brahmin family faces no ghettoisation and has free access to community resources like drinking and bathing water because of their caste. In contrast, the lower-caste family leaves in an area earmarked for people of their caste, segregated from the rest of the village by a fence and have no access to the community resources mentioned above. It’s irrelevant to reiterate that such situations are not figments of my imagination but realities in many villages in the state mentioned, as also in quite a few other states of the Union of India. The National Crime Records Bureau in its last published report reflects a 19 percent increase in crimes against Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe people across the country between 2013 and 2014. These atrocities range from lynching and arson to rape and murder. The Brahmin family has more chances of starving to death, possibly, but the Dalit family lives with the omnipresent possibility of facing any kind of monstrosity, up to being burnt alive inside their home for unwittingly breaking some norm that they may not even be aware of. Some social custom forbidden by the law of the land, but practised anyway. Can we really say that the Dalit family is less of an underdog because they eat somewhat more than the members of the Brahmin family?

 

Gender discrimination is the other oft-referred tool of oppression; girls and women are on the receiving end of such discrimination, making them underdogs in a male-dominated patriarchal society such as ours. True, but issues around the kinds and degrees of underdog-hood/-ness seem to be far too complex to be resolved easily. I cannot remember exactly how and where I read this piece of information, but just reflect a little on this situation. A village somewhere in erstwhile Andhra Pradesh (it was certainly before the creation of Telengana, that much I remember) with a majority of Dalit inhabitants was occupied by the Maoists and declared a liberated zone. Apparently, Dalit women of this village had faced being systematically raped by upper-caste men for decades and one of their demand post “liberation” was that the Dalit men rape upper-caste women. Who are the real underdogs here? Dalit women who had been facing organised violations over a pretty long period of time, most certainly, but can we say that the upper caste women were any less of an underdog—living with the knowledge that their menfolk were deliberate rapists? Or, must we presume that all upper caste women were in support of such action against Dalit women, even if tacitly? For me, that’s too much of a simplification, but the demand of the lower-caste women makes me wonder. “Women are their own worst enemies”—are they? Or, a case of two hungry packs of wolves fighting over a little bit of meat that will relieve the hunger of none? Who is the underdog here? Both groups of women, or neither?

Such problems in deciding who the underdog is in any given situation are real issues, rather than imagined ones, though seldom articulated with any clarity and purpose—in the election manifestos of political parties as much as in the programmes of the social development sector.

Such problems in deciding who the underdog is in any given situation are real issues, rather than imagined ones, though seldom articulated with any clarity and purpose—in the election manifestos of political parties as much as in the programmes of the social development sector. “Poorest of the poor” is a catchphrase for both vote-seekers and grant-aspirants for social development activism, but who the poorest of the poor are remains largely undefined. This ambiguity poses serious problems not only in large-scale government programmes being underutilised, but also problematises the achievement of real change through the actions of non-profit organisations in the social development sector.

It is taboo in this sector to question the internal dynamics of inequality and injustice within a population group identified as deserving beneficiaries. If economic poverty is in focus, then caste differences cannot be brought into question. If caste-based atrocities are the focal point of the movement for social justice, then gender oppression or violation of the rights of children within Dalit communities are to be overlooked. If the struggle is against the discrimination meted out to individuals with non-heteronormative gender-sexuality expressions and orientation, then rivalries within such communities and intimate partner violence issues are to be brushed aside.

There is certainly a price to be paid for such generalisations and deliberate obliteration of multiple points of oppression that constantly and continuously redefine who is an underdog when and how. Laws are passed without implementation mechanisms being put in place. Welfare schemes are either misused or remain underutilised. Rights are secured without those facing most violations even getting to know about such rights.

If by now readers are frowning or smirking in disdain against my apparently unsubstantiated claims, I welcome everyone to please let me know of any government scheme/social development organisation working specifically for equal rights and opportunities for a Dalit girl in her mid-teens, coming from a family facing death by starvation, having never benefited from any Integrated Child Development Centre in her village, never enrolled in any formal school, recognising that she feels attracted to other girls rather than to boys and thinking that she will be punished by God (of whichever religion) for such a sin, with no idea that same-sex attraction is no longer considered a ‘disorder’ in mental health discourse . . . This girl, for sure, is an underdog and do we have anything for her—addressing all her discriminations comprehensively? I think not. We human rights and social development activists work too much in silos for that.

Paramita Banerjee works as an independent consultant in the sphere of child protection and gender justice. Her expertise lies in research, training, evaluation and community mobilisation. This black-coffee drinking queer activist dreams of wielding the pen to ruffle the feathers of status-quo-ist survival.

7 Comments

  • Reply December 21, 2025

    Casinospielhallen Cashback

    Es stehen Ihnen die gleichen Methoden zur Verfügung, die Sie auch für eine Mindesteinzahlung verwenden würden. Das gilt für alle legalen deutschen Spielhallen, die mit einer Lizenz arbeiten, die sich an den Glücksspielstaatsvertrag 2019 hält.
    Spieler, die mit aufregenden Spielen beginnen möchten, sollten eine Mindesteinzahlung von nur 10 € leisten. CrazyBuzzer bietet Methoden wie Mastercard,
    Visa, Sofort by Klarna, PayPal und Paylado an. Wenn Sie bereit sind, eine Mindesteinzahlung zu leisten, stehen Ihnen mehrere sichere Methoden zur Auswahl.

    Die casino Zahlungsmöglichkeiten werden bei CrazyBuzzer sehr ernst
    genommen, denn die Spieler suchen ein sicheres Umfeld, in dem sie Transaktionen durchführen können.
    Aufgrund der aktuellen deutschen Glücksspiellizenz können CrazyBuzzer
    und andere Online Spielotheken in Deutschland derzeit keine Tischspiele wie Roulette, Blackjack oder andere klassische Casino Spiele anbieten. Obwohl die Spielothek derzeit keine Tischspiele oder Live Dealer Optionen aufgrund der deutschen Lizenzbestimmungen anbietet,
    bleibt das Slot-Angebot umfangreich. Sie können alle
    bekannten Merkur Automaten online spielen, wie zum Beispiele Eye of Horus,
    El Torero und Magic Mirror oder Jokers Cap. Bevor Sie von den einzigartigen Willkommensbonus
    des CrazyBuzzer Casino profitieren und Spielautomaten und Tischspiele spielen können, müssen Sie natürlich ein Konto erstellen.
    Besuchen Sie auf jeden Fall unsere Webseite für Spielothek mit Mindesteinzahlung, um sich zu informieren. Das
    bedeutet, dass Sie keine Tischspiele wie Poker, Baccarat, Blackjack oder Roulette finden werden. Derzeit konzentriert sich CrazyBuzzer auf virtuelle Spielautomaten,
    was aufgrund seiner Betriebslizenz auch Sinn macht. Es gibt genügend Kategorien, damit Sie Ihre Lieblingsspiele auswählen können.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/revolution-casino-auszahlung-ihr-umfassender-leitfaden/

  • Wer gerne mit Kryptowährungen einzahlt,
    sich mit kleineren Bonusbeträgen zufrieden gibt und vor allem Spielauswahl pur bevorzugt, ist
    bei WazBee genau richtig. Jeder Spieler erhält in seinem persönlichen Konto somit
    regelmäßig Boni, die zu seinem individuellen Spielverhalten und Wetteinsatz passen. Die Webseite ist wie erwähnt erste seit Anfang dieses
    Jahres 2024 online und ich gehen davon aus, das dies sehr bald behoben ist.

    Ich musste ihn nicht in Anspruch nehmen, sah aber, dass ein schneller
    Kundensupport rund um die Uhr bereitstand.

    Ich habe mit Freude festgestellt, dass das WazBee Live-Casino
    eine bemerkenswerte Auswahl an Live-Blackjack
    Spielen bietet. Das WazBee Casino bietet mit seinem Live-Casino ein weiteres herausragendes Feature.
    Zu den beliebtesten Varianten gehören zweifellos Big
    Scratch, Scratch Gold und Lucky Scratch, von denen jedes seine
    eigene einzigartige Atmosphäre und Spannung bietet.
    Klassische Top Casino Tischspiele Klassiker wie Baccarat, Poker, Blackjack und Roulettes
    sind bei WazBee ebenfalls verfügbar!
    Dieser Reload-Bonus ist die beste Möglichkeit für Spieler, die
    den WazBee Willkommensbonus ausgeschöpft haben, zusätzliches Geld
    zu erhalten. Waltenberg hat Tausende von Online-Casinos, Spielautomaten und Casinospielen überprüft und verfügt über fundierte Kenntnisse zu
    Boni und Spielautomaten. Neben dem großzügigen Willkommensbonus
    bietet Wazbee Casino auch einen 15 EUR Bonus für das Werben von Freunden!

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/rizk-casino-promo-code-dein-umfassender-guide/

  • Initially launched back in December 2023, Deep
    Search now lets you try out this beta experience. You can also
    try out the new experience by clicking on the “Deep Search” button on Bing.

    Initially launched back in July this year, Bing generative
    search now lets you perform searches for more complex queries.
    Besides launching a revamped & refreshed Copilot look with features like ChatGPT-like “Copilot Voice”
    and Copilot Vision, the Redmond tech giant also announced the next
    phase of Bing generative search. Click to sign-in or sign-up.

    Existing Sky Q customers will continue to get the service they currently have and
    Sky will continue to support until there comes a time that they decide
    not to. Customers and potential customers
    need to get used to that fact. We all know that the satellite service is being wound down so there’s no point in them making it easy for
    people to sign up to service which will be
    shutting down in a few years. @BenJoBanjo @Daniel0210 
    the website does actually state sky Q queries can still be made via phone or visit a local
    store I’m going to mark this post as the current answer, so
    that everyone has the most up-to-date information. Alternatively,
    they can opt for one of our popular streaming
    products, Sky Glass and Sky Stream, which are chosen by
    9 in 10 of our new customers.
    When we try to use the Sky go app on the computer it does not work properly.
    Anybody with individual sports packs will need to
    upgrade. Only customers with the complete Sky Sports pack will get access
    to Sky Sports+ at no extra cost. As part of the Sky Sports+ launch, NOW members will also be able to
    pause and rewind live sports content for the first time.
    Integrated into Sky TV, streaming service NOW, and a revamped Sky Sports mobile app,
    Sky Sports+ will make it easier for fans to browse, discover
    and watch the sport they love. Launching this August, Sky Sports+ is transforming the amount of
    choice sports fans have, all at no extra cost

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/complete-list-of-las-vegas-casinos/

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    real money casino AU

    Then, you should make sure you pay attention, observe all
    the rules surrounding bonuses, making an informed decision before you make your choice.
    However, as with a lot of industries that use the world
    of cyberspace, finding a reputable new online slots site or live dealer website can be tricky business – and that is where we come in. Yes, regulations have become somewhat more tough and binding, but that just means that players
    get a much fairer deal. We list all of the newly licenced operators that are properly regulated and licenced by the UKGC –
    so all you have to do is check the list, find a website that appeals to you and start playing.
    The UKGC has been set up specifically for people who live and reside in the United
    Kingdom which includes England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland to provide a regulatory
    framework that ensures player safety whichever site they choose to play at.
    We’ve already seen many casinos try and fail in the wearable technology space.

    This guide breaks down the current state of online casino gaming in New York,
    highlighting what’s allowed, what’s not, and what you can do in the meantime.

    For casino fans, navigating New York’s online casino market and understanding where and how you can play can be
    confusing. Regulated new casinos use secure encryption,
    RNG-tested games, and independent auditing to keep things fair.
    Firstly, these new platforms often have great offers
    to attract players.
    Whether you’re chasing the best new real money casino Australia has to offer or just want to see what’s new on the scene, we’ve got you covered.

    We’ll walk you through the newest casinos, checking out their licences, payment options, free spins,
    and welcome deals so you can play with confidence. You can get free spins, deposit
    matches, and more from many new casino welcome offers.

    We determine whether the dedicated online casino apps are for iOS/Android
    or optimized mobile web browsers. Part of our online casino review process is to test the mobile platform.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/how-to-get-casino-bonus-codes-to-boost-the-casino-playing-experience/

  • Rivaling patient care in some of the finest hospitals,
    AirMed air ambulances are equipped for virtually every critical care scenario.
    AirMed offers unparalleled medical care and bedside-to-bedside transportation on a worldwide basis and boasts
    the most experienced air medical crews in the industry.
    AirMed International is the leading air ambulance and
    medical transport company in the United States, with 25,000
    total missions and counting. There are a lot of misperceptions about the cost of air
    medical transport. Air Methods has a talented workforce of over 4,500 team members, which includes
    the best in the air medical industry.
    We assist with bill resolution options, including insurance negotiations,
    and payment plans, often reducing charges. Patient Financial Services advocates for patients, guiding them through the financial process after a flight.
    FlyPHI is a mobile and web-based application that supports PHI
    Air Medical partners by electronically requesting
    a helicopter. We safely transport more than 22,500 patients each year, operating out of more than 82
    bases across the United States. And unlike others in the industry, we have
    our own fleet so we can guarantee a quality medical flight and exceptional
    care across the board. Visit our online patient and
    family center for all the resources and assistance you need to
    get you through this tough time.
    These rankings were used to create “reward models” that were
    used to fine-tune the model further by using several iterations
    of proximal policy optimization. The ethics of
    its development, particularly the use of copyrighted
    content as training data, have also drawn controversy. The chatbot can facilitate academic dishonesty, generate misinformation, and create malicious code.
    It uses generative pre-trained transformers (GPTs), such as
    GPT-5, to generate text, speech, and images in response to user prompts.
    ChatGPT is a generative artificial intelligence chatbot
    developed by OpenAI, and released in November 2022.

    By joining PHI Cares, you are becoming a member of a national
    air ambulance membership program that gives you peace of mind.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/60_platinum-club-vip-casino_rewrite_1/

  • These games offer a great way to relax during breaks or kill time while avoiding the frustration of access issues.
    Luckily, we’ve put together a comprehensive Unblocked
    Games Backup List to help you access all your favorite games with ease.
    Some games need to be published in order to work properly.
    Contributions to improve these games or add features
    are welcome! A classic memory card game where the objective is to find all
    matching pairs of cards on a 4×4 grid.
    Welcome to the most comprehensive, unique list of game hacking resources on the web!
    These links lead to reliable sources where you can play a wide variety of games
    without encountering network restrictions.
    Below is a curated list of backup links to unblocked game websites.
    A repository with more than 400 popular Roblox games with their source
    code.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/free-online-slots-play-the-best-free-slots/

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    kaswece.org

    online casinos that accept paypal

    References:
    kaswece.org

Leave a Reply