Mapping Cartographies of Silence

QFTL illustration

I am going to pack my two shirts with my other socks and my best suit in the little blue cloth my mother used to tie round her hair when she did the house, and I am going from the Valley
—Huw Morgan, How Green Was My Valley

Huw would never return to the Valley of his early childhood—a rural mining community in South Wales. The Valley would stand silent witness to tales of adversity, resistance, and resilience and to memories of endurance, exploitation and empathy.

Nearer home, the tea valleys of Assam also narrate similar stories of pain, suffering, confrontation and fortitude. More than 50 percent of India’s tea production and one-sixth of the world’s production emerge from the state of Assam. Tea, we assume, has the potential to transform and rejuvenate. However, the fecundity of the harvest is inversely proportional to the conditions of tea workers in the plantations. Tea workers in Assam today are descendants of Indigenous communities from Jharkhand, Orissa, Chhatisgarh who had been forcibly removed and transplanted from their ancestral lands to work on the plantations almost hundred and fifty years ago. Sobhita Jain notes:

Problems related to their differences in origin made it difficult for them to achieve some kind of consensus for a new social order in terms of their traditional social relationships. The web of caste relationships as existing in the typical setting of an Indian village or town never came into being. The reconstitution of a new community took place in terms of the paternalistic relationships between the higher and lower participants in the plantation social system itself.[1]

Tea workers constitute 20 percent of Assam’s population and number more than 4.5 million[2]. NGOs, media, researchers have reported on the dismal conditions of the workers and the fact that their initial displacement led to the eradication of cultural identity and moorings. In an article on tea workers of Assam on the website of Action Aid explains, “The Plantation Labour Act 1951 (PLA), which regulates the wages of tea-garden workers, their duty hours and the amenities that the management is supposed to provide such as housing, drinking water, education, health care, child care facilities like crèche, accident cover and protective equipment, has not been implemented. Amenities, where provided, are of very poor quality.”[3]

Tea workers constitute 20 percent of Assam’s population and number more than 4.5 million. NGOs, media, researchers have reported on the dismal conditions of the workers and the fact that their initial displacement led to the eradication of cultural identity and moorings.

In 1937, Mulk Raj Anand had portrayed the dreary life of the tea workers of Assam in his symbolic novel Two Leaves and A Bud within the structural compulsions of plantation production in British India. Anand’s narrative of suffering, exploitation and also protest find a resonance in contemporary times as well. Colonial histories impinge upon the neo-imperial global processes of the plantations today. Cultural and political economies of the tea plantations may also be connected to regional, textured stories which cross seemingly impermeable borders—in quest for “a paradise to be gained, new fields of edenic cultivation.”

 

Tea—its leaf and the liquid—has in fact been emblematic of imperial conquest and global expansion. In A Time for Tea, Piya Chatterjee writes, “With all its accoutrements of porcelain jars and delicate cups, bamboo whisks and brocade, the culture around tea drinking would come to signify the consuming pleasures of discovery.”[4] Annadashankar Ray’s rhyme in Bangla, ‘Obaak Cha Paan’ (literally, Amazing Tea Drinking) speaks of a tea party which involves all from the cats and the dogs to Baba Babu, partaking the limpid liquid in earthen and porcelain cups, and even in saucers every evening. It’s a regimented ritual integral to the imperialist ambitions of an empire.  In fact, the “discovery” of the tea plant in Assam in the early 1820s facilitated the East India Company to embark on a flourishing trade that had hitherto been monopolized by China.

Ironically, the “discovery” has been appropriated as a pioneer tale of Scottish cultivators and brothers, Robert Bruce and Charles Bruce. Indeed, it was Charles Bruce (since Robert Bruce died early in 1824) who collected the tea plants and sent them to be tested at the Botanical Gardens in Calcutta, where the superintendent, Dr Nathaniel Wallich declared that the species was different from the ones in China. Dr Wallich would visit Assam in 1834 and in the following year, he would submit his report. In 1839, the Assam Company would be formed in England with a capital of five lakh rupees, with his headquarters in Nazira and the oldest extant commercial tea company of Assam. This would be followed by the Jorhat Tea Company in 1859.

What is often bypassed in this seamless trajectory of the flourishing tea trade in Assam is the story of a certain Maniram Dutta Baruah or a Maniram Dewan.

What is often bypassed in this seamless trajectory of the flourishing tea trade in Assam is the story of a certain Maniram Dutta Baruah or a Maniram Dewan. Popularly known as Kalita Raja, Maniram Dewan (1806–58), was one of the last ministers of the Ahom court. Maniram’s family had sought political asylum in British East India Company controlled Bengal, after the Burmese invasions of Assam (1817–26). The family would eventually return to Assam under British protection and as staunch British loyalists during the First Anglo-Burmese War (1824–26) and the Treaty of Yandabo (1826) would ensure British supremacy in Assam.

A 22-year-old Maniram would be deputed as tehsildar and sheristadar of Rangpur in Sivsagar district of Assam. He would also be designated as borbhandhar or Prime Minister of the titular Ahom king, Purandar Singha. He would resign from his posts of tehsildar and sheristadar once the British deposed the king. However, it was Maniram who had drawn the attention of Robert Bruce to the tea leaves, grown by the Singhpos. Moreover, he had facilitated the meeting between Bruce and the Singhpo chief, Bessa Gam. Maniram’s position of prestige within the local community facilitated the permission for the Bruce brothers to collect samples of the tea and send them to Calcutta. He became a member of the board of the Assam Company and its Dewan at Nazir.

As one of the nine Indian shareholders of the Assam Company, Maniram Dewan held seven percent of the Company’s stock and drew a higher salary than most of the Company’s European staff.[5] By the time he left the company in the mid- 1840s, Maniram had himself acquired tea plantations at Cheimora at Jorhat and Selung at Sibsagar. By exhibiting a versatile indigenous entrepreneurship and being part of the Assam zamindari system, Maniram posed a threat to the hegemony of British elite plantation owners, by creating a shadow plantocracy. On one hand, an ‘outsider’ (the colonised subject), Maniram had been an important ally/ broker for the sahibs. On the other, his indigenous position of feudal prestige and lineage involved social allegiances to plantations and village communities, which functioned beyond the epistemological framework of colonial rule.

By exhibiting a versatile indigenous entrepreneurship and being part of the Assam zamindari system, Maniram posed a threat to the hegemony of British elite plantation owners, by creating a shadow plantocracy.

In fact, by the 1850s, Maniram would be antagonistic towards British rule. In 1852, he filed a petition with the then Sudder Court judge in Calcutta, AG Moffat Mills, lamenting the exploitation of local economy in Assam, unjust taxations, desecration of Ahom royal tombs and the discontinuation of puja at the Kamakhya temple. He advocated the restoration of Ahom rule, which was summarily dismissed by Judge Mills[6]. Chatterjee writes, “[Maniram’s] his allegiances and alliances were layered and subterranean and in the end, more faithful to the political and cultural web of his ‘native’ Assamese elite class and the communities through which this class conducted its terms of rule.”[7]

In April 1857, Maniram would arrive in Calcutta, the then British capital, to garner support for Ahom rule and when in May 1857, the “Sepoy Mutiny” broke out, Maniram felt this to be an opportunity to wage a “war of independence”. He planned to start an armed insurrection to overthrow British rule and to restore Kandarpeswar Singha as the Ahom king. Messengers in the guise of fakirs and bhats were sent to Peali Barua, the chief advisor to Kandarpeswar Singha in the absence of Maniram. Ammunition and support from local sepoys and influential Assamese were collected and a march was planned to Jorhat on the day of Durga Puja when Kandarpeswar would be crowned king.

However, Maniram’s letters had been intercepted by the Deputy Commissioner Charles Holroyd through the devious offices of the daroga of Sivsagar thana, Haranath Parbatia Barua. Maniram was arrested in Calcutta and sent to Assam for trial. On 26 February, 1858, both Peali Barua and Maniram Dewan would be publicly hanged in Jorhat.[8] Maniram’s death invoked widespread protest in Assam and George Williamson Inc., the British proprietors of Maniram’s estates consequently faced great labour unrest. Decades after his death, Maniram would be enshrined as a martyr in bihu songs and become the stuff that legends are made of. The 1964 movie on Maniram Dewan with Bhupen Hazraika’s Buku Hum Hum Kare would rekindle interest in the man. Maniram by then had transformed into the rebel who tried to dismantle the power nexus of the British in Assam.

What would be forgotten in the story would be Maniram’s contribution towards making that first cup of tea, which led to the burgeoning of one of Assam’s largest industries.

What would be forgotten in the story would be Maniram’s contribution towards making that first cup of tea, which led to the burgeoning of one of Assam’s largest industries. He would be the one to brew a cup with a whiff of an anticolonial and nationalist flavour.

As one travels today through the lush green foothills, the narratives of the tea workers and Maniram Dewan spin a resilient tale of assertion, silence and paradox. A cup of tea offers visions of an empire, derides quaint nostalgia, etches corporeal memories and strings a polyphony of voices that must be heard.

Perhaps, it’s time to brew another cup, unraveling cartographies of memory and power?

 

[1] Jain, Sobhita. ‘Acculturation Process on an Assam Tea Garden’, The Eastern Anthropologist, 44:1, Jan.-March, 1991, p. 37.

[2] http://nazdeek.org/where-we-work/india/ Accessed 18 May, 2016

[3] http://www.actionaid.org/india/what-we-do/assam/rights-tea-garden-workers-assam Accessed 18 May, 2016

[4] Chatterjee, Piya. A Time for Tea: Women, Labor, and Post/colonial Politics on an Indian Plantation. New Delhi: Zubaan, 2003. 21

[5] Quoted in Chatterjee 2003: 97

[6]  Sharma, Suresh K. Documents on North-East India: Assam (1664-1935). New Delhi: Mittal Publications, 2006. pp. 95–99

[7] Chatterjee 2003: 104

[8] Sharma, Anil Kumar. Quit India Movement in Assam. New Delhi: Mittal Publications, 2007.  pp. 9-10

Debashree Dattaray teaches in the Department of Comparative Literature, Jadavpur University, Kolkata. She loves her job as it involves reading, writing, talking, listening, travelling and getting paid for the same. Debashree has been the recipient of a CICOPS Fellowship at University of Pavia, Italy, a Fulbright-Nehru Visiting Lecturer Fellowship at UC Berkeley, the Erasmus Mundus Europe Asia Fellowship at the University of Amsterdam and Fulbright Doctoral Fellowship at State University of New York, Stony Brook. She is author of Oral Traditions of the North East: A Case Study of Karbi Oral Traditions (CAS Work in Progress IV Jadavpur University, Kolkata, 2015.)

14 Comments

  • Reply December 21, 2025

    beste casino app mobile

    Um heute 30 Freispiele zu erhalten, zahlen Sie einfach €20 ein,
    geben Sie den Code SPINS30 ein und spielen Sie einen beliebigen berechtigten Slot aus
    der Liste in der Lobby. Wir haben Dendera Casino gründlich überprüft und ihm einen sehr
    niedrigen Sicherheitsindex gegeben, das bedeutet, dass wir dieses Casino nicht für sicher halten, um darin zu spielen. Mit dem Schwerpunkt auf Fairness, Transparenz und verantwortungsvollem Spielverhalten bietet das Dendera Casino eine
    sichere und angenehme Umgebung für Spieler, um die Welt des Online-Spielens zu erkunden.
    Die Glücksspieler aus Deutschland erhalten Zugang zu über 300+ neuesten Spielautomaten,
    professionellen Bewertungen sowie zuverlässigen und unvoreingenommenen Bewertungen zahlreicher internationaler Casinos.
    Sobald das Casino den Code akzeptiert, erhalten Sie sofort Ihr Bonusgeld oder Ihre Spins, jedoch nur in €.

    Um diese üppige Belohnung zu beanspruchen, müssen die Spieler nur vernünftige Anforderungen erfüllen und können dies ganz einfach von Anfang
    an tun. Der scharfe Support ist rund um die Uhr über mehrere Kanäle verfügbar und bietet
    ein problemloses Erlebnis, selbst für die anspruchsvollsten Spieler.

    Die Plattform bietet auch eine Live-Casino-Option, bei der professionelle Dealers ein immersives Erlebnis bieten.
    Die Lobby ist leicht zu umgehen, da sie Kategorien, eine Suche nach Titel und Filter nach
    Anbieter oder Funktion bietet. Windows-, macOS- und Android-Tablets können alle die
    Browserversion verwenden. Eine kleine App namens Dendera Casino bietet alles, was Sie brauchen.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/legzo-casino-login-ihr-weg-zum-spielvergnugen/

  • Reply December 21, 2025

    N1 Casino Auszahlung

    Der Glücksspielstaatsvertrag und alle relevanten Gesetze werden von uns vollständig eingehalten, um
    legal und sicher spielen zu können. Wir
    stellen Ihnen umfassende Werkzeuge zur Verfügung,
    um Ihr Spielverhalten zu kontrollieren und verantwortungsvoll zu spielen. Der Glücksspielstaatsvertrag wird
    dabei vollständig berücksichtigt, um legal in Deutschland spielen zu können. Ein besonderer Vorteil für
    Live Casino Spieler ist das exklusive live casino cashback, das als zusätzliche
    Belohnung für Ihre Einsätze angeboten wird. Live-Casino-Spielshows spielen bedeutet, Teil einer aufregenden Show zu werden, die
    Casino-Action mit Entertainment-Elementen verbindet. Chat-Funktionen ermöglichen es Ihnen, mit den Dealern und anderen Spielern zu interagieren,
    während Sie um echtes Geld spielen.
    Die meisten Online Casinos bieten eine mobile
    Version ihrer Plattform an, die speziell für Smartphones und Tablets optimiert ist.
    Viele unserer Kunden schätzen besonders die große Spielauswahl, die attraktiven Bonusangebote und den zuverlässigen Kundenservice.

    Als legale Online Spielothek bieten wir ein sicheres und reguliertes Spielumfeld für Spieler aus Deutschland und Österreich.

    Im RocketPlay Casino bieten wir Ihnen Zahlungen per Kryptowährungen an.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/snatch-casino-freispiele-alles-was-sie-wissen-mussen/

  • Reply December 21, 2025

    NetBet Casino Bewertung

    Ausgestattet mit der Lizenz zum Töten bricht Geheimagent James Bond zu seiner ersten Mission als 007 auf.

    In unserem Moviepilot-Podcast diskutieren wir regelmäßig über neue Serien, Filmhighlights und
    geben dir die besten Tipps für dein nächstes Streaming-Abenteuer.
    Falls du auf der Suche nach ähnlichen Filmen bist, lohnt sich ein Blick in unser Streaming-Programm.
    Die Veröffentlichung von Serien und Filmen auf Streaming-Plattformen mit Flatrates erfolgt oft zeitnah zum Blu-ray- oder DVD-Start, also etwa 6–12 Monate nach
    der Erstausstrahlung oder dem Kinostart. Doch das spektakul�re Finale mit einer b�sen �berraschung steht noch aus …

    Im Film ist das Fahrzeug zusätzlich mit mehreren Schubfächern und schallgedämpfter Walther P99, Antidot-Ampullarium und Automatisiertem Externen Defibrillator (AED) ausgerüstet.
    Januar 2006 mit einem Budget von rund 150 Millionen US-Dollar und wurden am 21.
    In einer Komparsenrolle tritt auch das deutsche 1960er-Jahre-Model Veruschka auf.

    144min – Deutsch, Englisch, Französisch Aktuell auf 8 Streaming-Diensten & zusätzlich auf Disc verfügbar.
    Alles in allem wurde das Fazit geschlossen, dass ein exzellenter, mitreißender und spannender Film gedreht wurde
    mit bekannten Hauptdarstellern, die alle großes Schauspieltalent gezeigt haben. Als Bond das erfährt und es zu einem Kampf mit dem Terroristen kommt, stirbt
    seine große Liebe. Mr. White ist in Wirklichkeit ein Terrorist,
    doch das ist Bond egal, weil er bei M16 kündigt, um
    mit Vesper sein Leben in Ruhe zu genießen. Le Chiffre ist
    raffiniert und weiß, mit wem er es beim Spielen zu tun.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/robocat-casino-cashback-ihr-weg-zu-mehr-spielguthaben/

  • Reply December 26, 2025

    ultimate casino experience

    Planned to be Sydney’s first six-star luxury hotel resort, this is destined to be
    a magnificent facility that’s defined by Crown’s attention to detail,
    desire to be the finest, and commitment to providing the ultimate casino experience.
    Elevate your Sydney nights with world-class performances, high-end bars,
    harbourfront lounges, and unforgettable experiences available exclusively at Crown Sydney.
    Enjoy priority access to Crown’s gaming salons, exclusive restaurants, luxury shopping, and 24/7 concierge service.
    With its sophisticated layout, exclusive member access, and premium service, Crown Sydney
    offers a curated selection of games designed for the most discerning players in Australia and beyond.
    Discover the pinnacle of elegance at Barangaroo — exclusive
    gaming, harbour views, elite dining, and luxury accommodation await.

    The gaming operation has 160 tables, plus 66 electronic tables across the
    Crystal Room and 30 private salons on the Mahogany floor. Due to
    the potential of trace allergens in the working environment and supplied ingredients, Crown Sydney cannot guarantee completely
    allergy-free dining experiences. Our events team can personalise the private dining experience to suit your occasion. The Crown Sydney Resort is comprised of
    Crown’s signature Crown Towers Sydney hotel, in addition to Crown Spa,
    11 restaurants and bars, as well as luxury retail shopping.

  • AI-powered customer service bots are automated systems that use artificial intelligence to
    manage customer interactions. AI bots are designed
    to handle repetitive tasks while improving the
    overall customer experience through personalized, context-aware
    conversations. Go to the ChatBot dashboard, select your chatbot, and click on the “Publish” button in the top right corner of your screen.
    Chatbots can make it easy for users to find information by
    instantaneously responding to questions and requests through text input, audio input, or both, without
    the need for human intervention or manual research. True to its promise of
    not requiring any code, the course teaches how to visually create chatbots with Watson Assistant and how to deploy them online through a handy WordPress plugin. Learn to create useful chatbots without writing
    any code in IBM’s Building AI Powered Chatbots Without Programming course.

    Looking to leverage the benefits of chatbots
    in your job?

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/playamo-casino-safe-online-casino-in-australia/

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    elite gaming australia

    The FTC asked OpenAI for comprehensive information about its technology and privacy safeguards, as well
    as any steps taken to prevent the recurrence of situations
    in which its chatbot generated false and derogatory content about people.
    In July 2023, the FTC launched an investigation into OpenAI,
    the creator of ChatGPT, over allegations that the company scraped
    public data and published false and defamatory information. Italian regulators assert that
    ChatGPT was exposing minors to age-inappropriate content, and that OpenAI’s
    use of ChatGPT conversations as training data could violate
    Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation. In September 2025, following the
    suicide of a 16-year-old, OpenAI said it planned to add restrictions for users under
    18, including the blocking of graphic sexual content and
    the prevention of flirtatious talk.
    OpenAI’s new Applications CEO, Fidji Simo, called Pulse the
    first step toward bringing high-level personal support to everyone,
    starting with Pro users. The move comes amid growing regulatory
    scrutiny and a lawsuit over the chatbot’s alleged role in a teen’s suicide.
    In some of these countries, users can pay in local currencies, while in others, payments are required in USD, with final costs varying due to local taxes.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/win2aud-australia-online-casino-pokies-sports-betting/

  • YouTube Universal Links make it easy to move between the YouTube app and other apps on your iOS device.
    Download the YouTube app for a richer viewing experience on your smartphone.

    Whether you’re looking to enjoy classic casino games, try your
    luck with live dealers, or explore exciting slot games, Lukki
    Casino has it all. You can enjoy a smooth gaming experience without the need for an app, as the
    mobile site offers the same high-quality interface
    as the desktop version. In addition to this, the casino
    regularly hosts tournaments and giveaways, making it even easier to win exciting prizes while playing your favorite games.
    Lukki Casino is generous with its bonuses, offering new
    players a warm welcome with substantial welcome bonuses and free spins.
    You won’t have trouble finding your favorite games, account details, or promotions, thanks to the well-organized
    menu and straightforward layout.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/best-casinos-in-singapore/

  • Reply December 27, 2025

    Bitkingz games

    The Treasury Casino offers are everything from archaic to modern gameplay.
    Treasury Brisbane Casino has closed.Please visit
    thestarbrisbane.com.au. Digital gift cards only require 24 hours for
    delivery. This is appealing to golfers who want more control over launch
    angle and face angle at impact, allowing for even finer tuning
    of ball flight compared to the R1’s three-way adjustability system.

    The Titleist 910D2 Driver is a strong contender in the same
    price range, offering similar adjustability features and a focus on distance control.
    It features a 460cc head with a wide and deep face that is more forgiving
    on mis-hits and suitable for mid to low handicappers.
    With the impressive collection of 1,600 Gaming Machines and 8 Poker
    tables, the casino offers an abundant array of games to suit every player’s style and preference.
    Treasury Casino Brisbane, an iconic gaming destination since 1995, offers an immersive gaming experience,
    drawing players with its Poker tables, Gaming Machines, and captivating atmosphere.

    These Treasury Casino games are available 24/7 with more tables open during peak times.

    The TaylorMade R1 driver caters to golfers seeking maximum
    distance and control over their drives. For a seamless and enhanced shopping experience, please select
    your store to discover options near you. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser.
    Reset multiple control values and all the controls within a form Let’s
    run the app and click on the Update the button.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/casino-canberra-in-depth-review/

  • This guide is designed for users from Australia who want to start playing on RocketplayCasino safely and
    with maximum benefits. You need to enter the email that was used to
    create your account. Both options are convenient and will provide you with the best support service.

    Enjoy no deposit bonuses, free chips, cashback deals, and exclusive rewards just for logging in.
    From classic slots to live dealer games, poker, roulette, and more —
    powered by the industry’s top providers. We support multiple currencies and countries, with
    instant deposits and lightning-fast withdrawals.
    Even though the site is new in the online gambling arena, the
    casino contains about 4000 titles from over 40 software developers.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/this-is-vegas-casino-review/

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    giaovienvietnam.vn

    online roulette paypal

    References:
    giaovienvietnam.vn

  • Reply December 29, 2025

    fact18.com

    casino online uk paypal

    References:
    fact18.com

  • Reply December 30, 2025

    hirekaroo.com

  • Reply December 30, 2025

    jobspaceindia.com

Leave a Reply